Mental Health

Reframing Suicide: A Compassionate Psychological Perspective

Describing suicide as “selfish” is a common but deeply problematic and oversimplified perspective. From a psychological point of view, suicide is rarely an act of selfishness—instead, it is more often the result of intense psychological pain, distorted cognitive processing, and a perceived absence of alternatives. As hard as this view is, from a Psychological perspective we need to view this with a compassionate understanding.

Jody Eiser
Jody
4 min read
2 views
Reframing Suicide: A Compassionate Psychological Perspective

Here are a few key points to understand this better:

Cognitive Distortions and Psychological Risk Factors

People experiencing suicidal ideation often suffer from cognitive distortions, such as:

Black-and-white thinking (“Nothing will ever get better.”)

A sense of hopelessness (“There is no point in continuing.”)

Perceived burdensomeness (“Everyone would be better off without me.”)

These distortions, which have been found in psychological autopsy studies, are symptomatic of conditions like major depressive disorder, PTSD, bipolar disorder, or borderline personality disorder—they cloud perception and decision-making. Also, a history of self-harm increases suicide risk

Psychache (Psychological Pain) and Suicide as Escape

Suicide is often an attempt to escape unbearable psychological pain, a concept coined by psychologist Edwin Shneidman. The individual isn’t trying to hurt others; they are trying to stop their own suffering, which feels inescapable. Studies show that chronic emotional distress and feelings of entrapment are major contributors to suicidal behavior.

Impaired Functioning and Decision-making

Mental illness often leads to impaired emotional regulation, problem-solving abilities, and impulse control. These impairments make it extremely difficult for someone to consider other options or reach out for help. Research findings from the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) suggests that individuals at risk for suicide often experience neurological changes affecting both decision-making and emotional processing.

Isolation and Social Disconnection

People at risk for suicide frequently feel isolated, disconnected, and misunderstood. Their social support may be minimal or feel inaccessible, reinforcing the sense that they have no place in the world.

Myth of Selfishness and Stigma

Labelling suicide as “selfish” is harmful as it:

Invalidates the real suffering the person is experiencing.

Contributes to stigma, which discourages help-seeking.

Shifts blame rather than fostering empathy and support.

From a therapeutic perspective, it’s more compassionate and effective to view suicidal behavior as a maladaptive coping mechanism—not a moral failing.

In Summary:

Rather than selfishness, suicide is usually an act driven by desperation, mental illness, and a collapse of coping resources. Psychological interventions aim to address the underlying distress and help individuals reconnect with meaning, support, and hope. Compassionate Approach needs to be applied.

 

About the Author

Jody Eiser

Jody

Specializations
Stress or AnxietyRelationship IssuesTrauma or PTSD
About

I have spent my life learning, growing, and continuing to evolve. My debut novel, The Way We Remember Fire, emerges from this deep well of human experience—blending raw intimacy with poetic depth to explore the messy, beautiful reality of healing, and the belief that every person deserves a love that lasts. Alongside my writing and therapy practice, I bring years of corporate experience in HR and leadership development, as well as creating programs for parents on managing stress for themselves and their children. Living with chronic pain throughout my life has further shaped my empathy, resilience, and commitment to supporting others on their own journeys of growth and healing.

Reframing Suicide: A Compassionate Psychological Perspective | Shemesh Health Blog | Shemesh Health